ADVERTISEMENT
  • About Us
  • Contact
  • Advertise
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
Sunday, August 7, 2022
No Result
View All Result
NEWSLETTER
Cayman Marl Road
  • Home
  • CMR Daily Buzz
  • Cayman’s Youth
  • Parliament
  • Live Show
  • COVID-19
  • Election 2021
  • Legal Notices
  • Entertainment
    • All
    • Events
    • Music
    Wives and mothers can now enter Miss Universe

    Wives and mothers can now enter Miss Universe

    Actor who lived in the Cayman Islands gives up major role after scandal

    Armie Hammer not employed at Cayman hotel

    Capella Music Festival returns to Cayman

    Capella Music Festival returns to Cayman

    ‘Summer Serenade’ to be held Friday

    ‘Summer Serenade’ to be held Friday

    Cayman approves banned artist

    Cayman approves banned artist

    Roy Bodden Symposium book launching Tuesday

    Roy Bodden Symposium book launching Tuesday

    Kirsty O’Sullivan wins National Playwriting Competition

    Kirsty O’Sullivan wins National Playwriting Competition

    Cayman Air Show returns for Queen’s Jubilee after 20-year break

    Cayman Air Show postponed due to bad weather

    Deputy Governor’s 5K Challenge Grand Cayman takes place Sunday

    Deputy Governor’s 5K Challenge Grand Cayman takes place Sunday

  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Food
    • Health
    • Medical Experts
    Health City surgeons get game-changing technology

    Health City surgeons get game-changing technology

    DEH Laboratory on its way to International Accreditation

    DEH Laboratory on its way to International Accreditation

    Diabetes makes a fatal heart attack more likely

    5 ways to lower your A1C

    More men in US get vasectomies as states ban abortion

    More men in US get vasectomies as states ban abortion

    HSA offers remote medical consultation to Little Cayman

    HSA offers remote medical consultation to Little Cayman

    12 new COVID positive travelers since Friday

    HSA to only do COVID testing for public health purposes

    Health City Cayman partners with OceanMed for Cayman’s first robotic surgery

    Health City Cayman partners with OceanMed for Cayman’s first robotic surgery

    Polio virus detected in London

    Polio virus detected in London

    United States bans Juul e-cigarettes

    United States bans Juul e-cigarettes

    Lack of full vaccine access for children explained

    FDA authorizes COVID vaccine for children as young as 6 months

    Trending Tags

  • Home
  • CMR Daily Buzz
  • Cayman’s Youth
  • Parliament
  • Live Show
  • COVID-19
  • Election 2021
  • Legal Notices
  • Entertainment
    • All
    • Events
    • Music
    Wives and mothers can now enter Miss Universe

    Wives and mothers can now enter Miss Universe

    Actor who lived in the Cayman Islands gives up major role after scandal

    Armie Hammer not employed at Cayman hotel

    Capella Music Festival returns to Cayman

    Capella Music Festival returns to Cayman

    ‘Summer Serenade’ to be held Friday

    ‘Summer Serenade’ to be held Friday

    Cayman approves banned artist

    Cayman approves banned artist

    Roy Bodden Symposium book launching Tuesday

    Roy Bodden Symposium book launching Tuesday

    Kirsty O’Sullivan wins National Playwriting Competition

    Kirsty O’Sullivan wins National Playwriting Competition

    Cayman Air Show returns for Queen’s Jubilee after 20-year break

    Cayman Air Show postponed due to bad weather

    Deputy Governor’s 5K Challenge Grand Cayman takes place Sunday

    Deputy Governor’s 5K Challenge Grand Cayman takes place Sunday

  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Food
    • Health
    • Medical Experts
    Health City surgeons get game-changing technology

    Health City surgeons get game-changing technology

    DEH Laboratory on its way to International Accreditation

    DEH Laboratory on its way to International Accreditation

    Diabetes makes a fatal heart attack more likely

    5 ways to lower your A1C

    More men in US get vasectomies as states ban abortion

    More men in US get vasectomies as states ban abortion

    HSA offers remote medical consultation to Little Cayman

    HSA offers remote medical consultation to Little Cayman

    12 new COVID positive travelers since Friday

    HSA to only do COVID testing for public health purposes

    Health City Cayman partners with OceanMed for Cayman’s first robotic surgery

    Health City Cayman partners with OceanMed for Cayman’s first robotic surgery

    Polio virus detected in London

    Polio virus detected in London

    United States bans Juul e-cigarettes

    United States bans Juul e-cigarettes

    Lack of full vaccine access for children explained

    FDA authorizes COVID vaccine for children as young as 6 months

    Trending Tags

No Result
View All Result
Cayman Marl Road
No Result
View All Result

Felder loses defamation case after Priestley’s “material irregularity” in obtaining default judgment

by CMR
December 09, 2021
in Civil
0
Felder loses defamation case after Priestley’s “material irregularity” in obtaining default judgment

Judgment in favor of Hill published today

35
SHARES
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on Whatsapp

(CMR) The Court released its 13-page written judgment from Judge The Honorable Justice Robin McMillan on Thursday afternoon giving his reasons for setting aside the default judgment against Cayman Marl Road's Sandra Hill. The court found that a “material irregularity in the granting of the original default judgment” was fatal to the entire process from that point on.

“Crucial evidence in relation to how the Default Judgement was proceeded upon and obtained was not adduced by the Plaintiff under circumstances where the Plaintiff had a legal obligation to adduce it”

McMillan accepted all of the grounds submitted in the November 2 Summons – which essentially acts to do away with the judgment. Now that the default judgment has been set aside the CI$105,000 judgment for damages by Acting Judge Carter will also be set aside.

The defamation case was brought against Hill in 2019 by John Felder, formerly of Cayman Automotive and Leasing who alleged that several articles written on CMR's website were libelous. Principally, he claimed that he had not been fired as was alleged by the articles. He also claimed that using the term “fraudster” to describe him was defamatory as he was a well-respected businessman.

The lawsuit was served on Hill who did not file a defense against it despite indicating that she intended to do so. A July attempt to have the matter set aside by Hill herself was unsuccessful based on a technicality. However, in November Kyle Broadhurst from Broadhurst Attorneys-at-Law reapplied to have the default judgment set aside on several grounds which the court accepted.

Priestley's Attorney's-at-Law did not serve the Statement of Claim outside the timeframe required by the Grand Court Rules. During the hearing they accepted that it was “an administration error” despite having several occasions to engage Hill's attorney prior to the hearing. They argued that despite the error the court should ignore it because their client would “suffer significant prejudice” if the judgment was set aside.

They went on to argue that Hill had suffered “no prejudice” because of their error. The judge's position was clear where he stated:

“With great respect to the Plaintiff, this is an over-simplification”.

Priestley's continued during the course of several hearings to not disclose the irregularity to the court. The error was discovered by Broadhurst after Hill retained legal counsel in September 2021. The court noted:

“A material irregularity has arisen and no effort has been made to correct it before the Default Judgment was both sought and obtained”.

Felder's attorneys blamed the earthquake in January 2020 for the oversight but the Judge noted that:

“While a major earthquake may well justify an application for an extension of time … it cannot justify taking no action at all and, even if unintentionally, leaving a material irregularity both uncorrected and unknown to the Court”

Acting Justice Carter then issued a substantial judgment against Hill of $105,00 based on a technical basis “without any hearing on the merits”. Realizing the gravity of the situation Justice McMillian noted:

“If the Defendant's recently appointed attorneys had not made enquiry of the Plaintiff's attorneys a full account of these events might never have become known.” 

Felder had several attorney's from the firm including David Lewis-Hall and James Dixon.

In August 2021 Hill attempted to settle the matter with the plaintiff after the judge suggested the parties go away and do their best to dispense with the matter amicably. Copied on that correspondence was Partner Daniel Priestley. Not only did they refuse to settle the matter but they also threatened additional litigation should Hill share the documents in her possession that proved the initial publications were not defamatory.

Speaking to CMR on Thursday Hill shared:

“This is quite an important lesson for me. Attorneys will not always get it right nor will they always do the right thing. A self represented person is at a disadvantage and should seek legal counsel. I am most grateful for the team at Broadhurst for their attention to detail and desire to see the right thing done. Having this judgment done away with is a significant burden lifted. I thank the judge also for his consideration of the relevant facts.”

Hill was made to take down the articles as part of the default judgment. However, now that the judgment has been set aside all articles can be restored on the website.

 

Join the CMR Community!

Join Cayman Marl Road on YouTube, Facebook or Instagram! for the latest discussions on all topical issues.

We welcome all viewpoints but ask for responsible commentary on our stories.

Have a tip for us? Email today!

 

Related posts:

Wilson Mendoza sentenced to jail
Felder to pay $50,000 in costs as defamation case dismissed
RCIPS officers sue helicopter manufacturer after hard landing
Governments sues businessman Winston Salmon for $22,000 in bad checks
Share your vote!


No, thanks.
How do you feel after reading this?
  • Fascinated
  • Happy
  • Sad
  • Angry
  • Bored
  • Afraid
Tags: Cayman Automotive Leasing & Sales Ltd.David Lewis-HallJames DixonJohn FelderPriestleys Attorneys at Law
CMR

CMR

Related Posts

Wilson Mendoza sentenced to jail

Wilson Mendoza sentenced to jail

by CMR
May 17, 2022
0

(CMR) Wilson Mendoza was jailed for seven days for being in contempt of court in an ongoing civil land dispute...

Felder to pay $50,000 in costs as defamation case dismissed

Felder to pay $50,000 in costs as defamation case dismissed

by CMR
April 24, 2022 - Updated on April 25, 2022
0

(CMR) Former Cayman Automotive Sales & Leasing Manager, John Felder, has agreed to pay the legal fees associated with a...

RCIPS officers sue helicopter manufacturer after hard landing

RCIPS officers sue helicopter manufacturer after hard landing

by Renae Stampp
March 3, 2022
0

(CMR) Chief pilot of the Royal Cayman Islands Police Service Nigel Pitt is one of two Air Operations Unit employees...

Governments sues businessman Winston Salmon for $22,000 in bad checks

Governments sues businessman Winston Salmon for $22,000 in bad checks

by CMR
March 1, 2022
0

(CMR) The Attorney General on behalf of the Cayman Islands Government is suing Winston James Salmon T/A G&A Spectacular Cleaning for...

Employer sues employee over cosmetic surgery loan

Employer sues employee over cosmetic surgery loan

by CMR
February 28, 2022
0

(CMR) The owner of Lash Out Limited is suing her former employee, Latoya Bartley, for an unpaid loan for cosmetic surgery...

Court injunction issued to rogue neighbors over vehicular access

Court injunction issued to rogue neighbors over vehicular access

by Renae Stampp
February 22, 2022 - Updated on May 17, 2022
0

(CMR) Rogue neighbors, Wilson Jonathan Mendoza and his wife Deaven Ann Mendoza, have been threatened with being jailed, fined or have...

Next Post
Government House bids farewell to Elsa after 26 years

Government House bids farewell to Elsa after 26 years

Recent News

Cayman wins gold in Squash at Commonwealth Games

Cayman wins gold in Squash at Commonwealth Games

August 7, 2022
Armed robbery at George Town liquor store

Armed robbery at George Town liquor store

August 7, 2022
Wives and mothers can now enter Miss Universe

Wives and mothers can now enter Miss Universe

August 6, 2022
International beach volleyball competition returns to Cayman

International beach volleyball competition returns to Cayman

August 6, 2022
Jamaica celebrates 60 years of Independence

Jamaica celebrates 60 years of Independence

August 6, 2022
NYE bar opening hours extended

Liquor licensing deadline approaching

August 5, 2022
  • About Us
  • Contact
  • Advertise
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions

Copyright © 2022 CMR Cayman's Premier News Source - All Rights Reserved

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • CMR Daily Buzz
  • Events
  • Election 2021
  • Cayman’s Youth
  • Legal Notices
  • Live Show
  • The Cold Hard Truth
  • Ask The Marl Road
    • Consumer Protection
    • COVID-19
    • What would you do?
  • Breaking News
  • Government
    • Road Closures
  • Rumor Has It
  • Investigative Reports
  • Business
    • Finance
  • Cayman Crime Watch
  • Celebration of Life
  • Community Notices/Events
    • Accidents
    • Police
    • Weather
  • Court Cases
    • Civil
    • Criminal
  • Entertainment
    • Events
    • Music
  • Family
    • Education
    • Fury Friends
  • Lifestyle
    • Food
    • Health
    • Medical Experts
  • News Roundup
  • Opinions
    • Polls
    • Cartoons
  • Politics
    • Parliament
  • Regional News
  • Social Media Happenings
    • Jackass of the Day!
    • Lost & Found
  • World News
  • Cayman Small Business
  • Cayman Wellness
  • Tech News
  • Sports
  • Science
  • Weird & Unusual News
  • Advertorials

Copyright © 2022 CMR Cayman's Premier News Source - All Rights Reserved