ADVERTISEMENT
  • About Us
  • Contact
  • Advertise
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
Friday, June 2, 2023
No Result
View All Result
NEWSLETTER
Cayman Marl Road
  • Home
  • CMR Daily Buzz
  • Cayman’s Youth
  • Parliament
  • Live Show
  • COVID-19
  • Election 2021
  • Legal Notices
  • Entertainment
    • All
    • Events
    • Music
    Actor who lived in the Cayman Islands gives up major role after scandal

    Armie Hammer will not face sexual assault charges

    London-based designer partners with local star for Art Week

    London-based designer partners with local star for Art Week

    Mobsta apologizes to fans

    Mobsta apologizes to fans

    Cayman to send first representative to Miss Supranational

    Cayman to send first representative to Miss Supranational

    PhotoVlog: Taste of Cayman 2023

    PhotoVlog: Taste of Cayman 2023

    Taste of Cayman goes digital

    Taste of Cayman goes digital

    Caymanian actress Grace Byers gives birth to baby boy

    Caymanian actress Grace Byers gives birth to baby boy

    Is Dancehall artist Spice pregnant?

    Dancehall artist Spice is not pregnant

    Koffee wins Best Reggae Grammy – setting records in the process

    Koffee gets into altercation with flight attendant

  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Food
    • Health
    • Medical Experts
    2,000 vaccines arrive for children 5-11

    Alzheimer’s Association gets $50,000 grant

    COVID-19 mandates return to Cayman as community cases confirmed

    HSA makes changes to visitation policy 

    First patients receive radiotherapy at Health City’s Oncology Centre

    First patients receive radiotherapy at Health City’s Oncology Centre

    Teens access ganja edibles through Bento App

    Teens access ganja edibles through Bento App

    Hospital on lockdown following mass shooting

    HSA awarded Joint Commission Gold Seal for safety and patient care

    Alex Panton Foundation hires two young Caymanians

    Alex Panton Foundation hires two young Caymanians

    Vaccinated primary contacts can now continue business as usual

    WHO declares end to COVID global health emergency

    MRCU aerial spraying to resume this week

    MRCU aerial spraying to resume this week

    Paleo and keto diets may harm heart health

    Paleo and keto diets may harm heart health

    FDA makes Narcan available without prescription

    FDA makes Narcan available without prescription

    Trending Tags

  • Home
  • CMR Daily Buzz
  • Cayman’s Youth
  • Parliament
  • Live Show
  • COVID-19
  • Election 2021
  • Legal Notices
  • Entertainment
    • All
    • Events
    • Music
    Actor who lived in the Cayman Islands gives up major role after scandal

    Armie Hammer will not face sexual assault charges

    London-based designer partners with local star for Art Week

    London-based designer partners with local star for Art Week

    Mobsta apologizes to fans

    Mobsta apologizes to fans

    Cayman to send first representative to Miss Supranational

    Cayman to send first representative to Miss Supranational

    PhotoVlog: Taste of Cayman 2023

    PhotoVlog: Taste of Cayman 2023

    Taste of Cayman goes digital

    Taste of Cayman goes digital

    Caymanian actress Grace Byers gives birth to baby boy

    Caymanian actress Grace Byers gives birth to baby boy

    Is Dancehall artist Spice pregnant?

    Dancehall artist Spice is not pregnant

    Koffee wins Best Reggae Grammy – setting records in the process

    Koffee gets into altercation with flight attendant

  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Food
    • Health
    • Medical Experts
    2,000 vaccines arrive for children 5-11

    Alzheimer’s Association gets $50,000 grant

    COVID-19 mandates return to Cayman as community cases confirmed

    HSA makes changes to visitation policy 

    First patients receive radiotherapy at Health City’s Oncology Centre

    First patients receive radiotherapy at Health City’s Oncology Centre

    Teens access ganja edibles through Bento App

    Teens access ganja edibles through Bento App

    Hospital on lockdown following mass shooting

    HSA awarded Joint Commission Gold Seal for safety and patient care

    Alex Panton Foundation hires two young Caymanians

    Alex Panton Foundation hires two young Caymanians

    Vaccinated primary contacts can now continue business as usual

    WHO declares end to COVID global health emergency

    MRCU aerial spraying to resume this week

    MRCU aerial spraying to resume this week

    Paleo and keto diets may harm heart health

    Paleo and keto diets may harm heart health

    FDA makes Narcan available without prescription

    FDA makes Narcan available without prescription

    Trending Tags

No Result
View All Result
Cayman Marl Road
No Result
View All Result

Landmark court ruling favors National Conservation Council

by Renae Stampp
August 24, 2022
in Court Cases
0
Government postponed Phase 3 re-opening until next year

Premier Wayne Panton

24
SHARES
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on Whatsapp

(CMR) In a landmark case that saw two government agencies disputing power and roles, Justice Alistair Walters ruled in favor of the National Conservation Council. Justice Walters said the Central Planning Authority (CPA) acted unlawfully when it approved an application to rebuild a cabana and seawall at Block 5B parcel 162 on Boggy Sand Road in West Bay.

In a decision released on 23 August 2022,  the Grand Court quashed this Planning approval, which was given contrary to direction from the NCC. The Court confirmed that the National Conservation Act (2013) provides the National Conservation Council (NCC) with the ability to direct government bodies in circumstances where actions could have an adverse effect on protected areas or species.

The 51-page decision confirms the NCC has the authority to direct any entity of the government – including ministries, departments, portfolios, statutory authorities, etc. – when the taking of any action by an entity would or would be likely to have an adverse effect directly or indirectly on a protected area or on the critical habitat of a protected species, where the adverse impact cannot be satisfactorily mitigated by conditions. In all other circumstances, the originating entity retains its decision-making authority.

The ruling also confirms the National Conservation Act provides the NCC with an express power of delegation, and that it is lawful for the NCC to delegate such powers to the Director of the Department of Environment (DoE), including the NCC's powers under section 41(5). These powers relate to the ability of the NCC to instruct an entity (including the CPA) to refuse any action that may give rise to an adverse effect on a protected area or the critical habitat of a protected species if the adverse effects cannot be mitigated by conditions of approval as specified by the DoE on behalf of the NCC.

Premier and Minister for Sustainability & Climate Resiliency, Hon. G. Wayne Panton, JP, MP, said the Grand Court's decision clarifies the important role the NCC plays in safeguarding protected areas and species in the Cayman Islands.

“Not only does this decision confirm the legal relationship between the National Conservation Council and the Central Planning Authority, but it also clarifies the implications for all other government entities, giving all parties greater certainty and clarity going forward. I would like to thank the Courts for their consideration of these important legal questions,” he said.

“As the ruling notes, the National Conservation Act is a bespoke piece of legislation, developed specifically to protect our invaluable, uniquely Caymanian marine and terrestrial habitats and species. A viable, functioning natural environment is foundational to a resilient economy and healthy communities,” he added.

The NCC sought the Court's consideration in 2021 after the CPA approved an application to rebuild a seawall and cabana on Boggy Sand Road in West Bay, counter to an NCC direction not to approve the project due to the potential for negative impacts on the surrounding marine protected area, namely the Seven Mile Beach Marine Reserve.

NCC Chairman McFarlane Conolly said the Council was pleased with the Court's ruling:

“This decision provides clarification on a fundamental difference of interpretation of the National Conservation Act between the NCC and CPA, which we tried many times to resolve before the NCC applied to the Court as a final recourse. The decision confirms the Council acted lawfully in its delegation of powers to the Director of the Department of Environment, and that we have acted in accordance with our legal mandate under the National Conservation Act,” he said.

Ministry of Sustainability & Climate Resiliency Chief Officer Jennifer Ahearn confirmed the decision to take the matter to the Grand Court was not taken lightly.

“We believe this ruling brings us closer to our constitutional mandate of ensuring the Cayman Islands Government shall, in all its decisions, have due regard to the need to foster and protect an environment that is beneficial to the health and well-being of present and future generations. We look forward to the CPA and other entities continuing to work more collaboratively with the NCC in their considerations,” she said.

Department of Environment Director Gina Ebanks-Petrie said the DoE welcomed the Court's decision.
“This decision will ensure environmental concerns are factored into decision-making processes across the Cayman Islands Government, particularly where actions may or are likely to have an adverse effect on a protected area or protected species critical habitat,” she said.

An attorney who spoke to CMR, requesting anonymity, said the ruling was perverse and could be overturned in the Court of Appeal.

“It's a perverse decision which, if appealed, will be overturned by the CoA. It's the worst judgment I've ever seen. It basically gives the Director of Environment the ability to intervene into the decision-making process of any statutory authority and direct them to refuse permission to anyone, no matter how meritorious their application may be, on the sole basis that SHE believes that their application may likely have a potentially adverse effect on the environment,” the attorney stated.

“Giving that kind of authority to a single civil servant flies in the face of established universal good governance standards and is NOT in keeping with the concept of a modern democratic society. That kind of arbitrary power being enjoyed by a government employee is exactly what defines a banana republic,” he added.

A copy of the full decision can be accessed at: https://conservation.ky/jr-23aug22/ 

Related posts:

Man convicted for arson denied appeal to overturn conviction
Man convicted in Czech Inn robbery loses appeal to reduce sentence
Woman injured in fatal crash sues police
Bodden Town man charged with arson
Share your vote!


No, thanks.
How do you feel after reading this?
  • Fascinated
  • Happy
  • Sad
  • Angry
  • Bored
  • Afraid
Tags: Cayman's National Conservation CouncilCentral Planning Authority
Renae Stampp

Renae Stampp

A regional writer with almost 10 years of experience working in various news media including two major media houses in Bermuda and Jamaica. Renae provides professional content for our regional and international audience.

Related Posts

Spence charged with arson of police office

Man convicted for arson denied appeal to overturn conviction

by Renae Stampp
May 16, 2023
0

(CMR) Rupert Spence,  who was convicted by a jury for torching a derelict car and setting fire to the RCIPS...

CPA to appeal landmark conservation case

Man convicted in Czech Inn robbery loses appeal to reduce sentence

by Renae Stampp
May 15, 2023
0

(CMR) A man convicted and sentenced to 14 years in prison for the 2018 robbery of Czech Inn Grill restaurant...

Children of the World

Woman injured in fatal crash sues police

by Renae Stampp
May 15, 2023
0

(CMR) A woman who was seriously injured in a fatal crash that occurred while the driver was reportedly being chased...

Selvin Caballero granted bail in child assault case

EMT Selvin Caballero found guilty of sexual assault

by Renae Stampp
May 12, 2023
0

(CMR) Selvin Senon Caballero (41), an EMT with the Health Services Authority, was found guilty of  Indecent Assault on a...

Two cars set ablaze in George Town

Bodden Town man charged with arson

by Renae Stampp
May 10, 2023
0

(CMR) A 43-year-old Bodden Town man whose vehicle collided with a fire truck in an attempt to flee the scene...

Pines Retirement closes to visitors after 10 residents test positive

Court rules woman denied fair hearing after COVID-related termination

by Renae Stampp
May 10, 2023
0

(CMR) The Grand Court has ruled that the Department of Labour and Pensions was discriminatory and breached the Bill of...

Next Post
Convicted gun smuggler arrested in Friday’s shooting

Leslie sentenced to 16 years for bar shootout

Recent News

Bank closures, acquisitions and voluntary separations?

CIBC to cease most over-the-counter transactions soon

June 1, 2023
TCHT: Bringing receipts for Mario

TCHT: Bringing receipts for Mario

June 1, 2023
Premier calls for diversity and inclusion on Government-appointed bodies

Premier urges public to be prepared for hurricane season

June 1, 2023
Tropical Depression 2 develops as hurricane season begins

Tropical Depression 2 develops as hurricane season begins

June 1, 2023
Actor who lived in the Cayman Islands gives up major role after scandal

Armie Hammer will not face sexual assault charges

June 1, 2023
BVI Premier’s  elderly mom tests positive for COVID-19 as cases spike

Former BVI Premier to stand trial alone in narcotics case

June 1, 2023
  • About Us
  • Contact
  • Advertise
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions

Copyright © 2023 CMR Cayman's Premier News Source - All Rights Reserved

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Ask The Marl Road
  • Breaking News
  • Business
    • Finance
  • Cayman Crime Watch
  • Cayman Small Business
  • Cayman Wellness
  • Cayman’s Youth
  • Celebration of Life
  • Community Notices/Events
    • Accidents
    • Police
    • Weather
  • Consumer Protection
    • Scammers
    • COVID-19
    • What would you do?
  • CMR Videos
    • The Cold Hard Truth
    • Cayman Voices
  • Court Cases
    • Civil
    • Criminal
  • Election 2021
  • Entertainment
    • Events
    • Music
  • Events
  • Family
    • Education
    • Fury Friends
  • Government
    • Road Closures
  • Investigative Reports
  • Legal Notices
  • Lifestyle
    • Food
    • Health
    • Medical Experts
  • Live Show
  • News Roundup
  • Opinions
    • Polls
    • Cartoons
  • Politics
    • Parliament
  • Regional News
  • Rumor Has It
  • Science
  • Social Media Happenings
    • Jackass of the Day!
    • Lost & Found
  • Sports
  • Tech News
  • Weird & Unusual News
  • World News
  • Sponsored Content

Copyright © 2023 CMR Cayman's Premier News Source - All Rights Reserved